Two Lump Sums, One Claim: Impairment Benefits vs Common Law Damages Explained

impairment benifit vs common law damages explained.

One of the most common conversations we have with new clients starts like this: “Someone told me I’d get a lump sum. Someone else told me I’d have to sue. Which is it?”

The answer, often, is both – or neither, or one and not the other. Victoria runs two completely separate lump sum pathways after an injury, and they are governed by different tests, different thresholds, different timeframes and different amounts. They can both arise from the same accident. Understanding the difference is the single most useful piece of knowledge an injured Victorian can have.

The short version

 

Impairment benefit

Common law damages

Based on

No fault – nobody has to be blamed

Fault – someone else’s negligence must be proved

What it measures

Permanent impairment, as a percentage

Your actual losses – pain and suffering, and economic loss

Gateway

A whole person impairment (WPI) percentage

A “serious injury”, plus proof of negligence

Who decides

An accredited impairment assessor and the insurer

The insurer, then the courts if disputed

Typical timing

From around 12 months after injury

Application generally not before 18 months after the event

Relative size

Modest to substantial, set by a published table

Potentially much larger, but harder to establish

Put plainly: the impairment benefit asks “how damaged are you?” Common law damages ask “who did this to you, and what has it cost you?”

Lump sum one: the impairment benefit

The impairment benefit – often called a permanent impairment benefit, or in TAC claims simply an impairment benefit – is paid without anyone having to prove fault. If you were injured at work or in a transport accident, the fact that nobody was careless does not stop you claiming it.

How it is assessed

Your injury must have stabilised. For WorkCover claims the Act sets a 12-month waiting period from the date of injury, with an exception allowing an earlier claim where the injury has already stabilised. WorkSafe’s public guidance describes stabilisation as usually at least 12 months after the injury.

You then attend an assessment with an accredited impairment assessor – a medical practitioner who has completed Minister-approved training in the relevant body system – who produces a whole person impairment percentage using the AMA Guides 4th Edition, with pain excluded from the calculation and unrelated or pre-existing impairment disregarded.

The claim is made on WorkSafe’s approved impairment benefit claim form and lodged with the agent, which then has 120 days to accept or reject liability for each injury, obtain the assessments and calculate the entitlement.

The thresholds

For Victorian workers, the entry points are:

  • Physical injury – 10% whole person impairment, with a separate narrower band for spinal impairment between 10% and 11%.
  • Psychiatric injury – 30% whole person impairment. This is a markedly higher bar, and it surprises people.
  • Hearing loss – assessed separately again, using the National Acoustic Laboratories procedures.

Physical, psychiatric and hearing loss entitlements are calculated separately, so a worker may receive more than one amount.

The money (2026/27)

Victorian figures are indexed each financial year, so always check the current table. As at the 2026/27 year, the WorkCover scale runs:

Whole person impairment

Amount

10% (physical, minimum)

$26,530

Each additional % between 10% and 30%

$3,980

Maximum for spinal impairment below 30%

$106,130

31%

$106,130

71%

$369,510

Above 80% (maximum)

$783,000

Psychiatric, minimum at 30%

$26,530

Loss of a foetus

$95,430

TAC impairment benefits work on a similar but separate scale. The threshold is 11% whole person impairment – a rating of 10% or less pays nothing. From 1 July 2026 the TAC table starts at $8,060 for the 11-19% band (rising $1,830 per percentage point) and runs to a maximum of $451,650 at 100%.

There is an important timing rule on the TAC side: an impairment benefit must generally be claimed within six years of the accident, or of when the injury first manifests. For someone injured as a child, the six years run from their 18th birthday. If six years pass without the TAC advising of a likely entitlement or requesting an assessment, the degree of impairment is taken to have been determined at 0%.

Lump sum two: common law damages

Common law damages are different in kind, not just in size. They are not a scheme benefit calculated from a table. They are compensation for what someone else’s negligence has actually cost you, and you have to prove it.

The two gates

To recover common law damages for a Victorian work injury you must clear both of the following:

  • Serious injury. Either an impairment assessment of 30% or more (which is deemed to be serious injury), or a finding under the narrative test that your injury is a “serious injury” as the legislation defines it. The statutory limbs are permanent serious impairment or loss of a body function; permanent serious disfigurement; permanent severe mental or permanent severe behavioural disturbance or disorder; or loss of a foetus.
  • Negligence. Someone other than you must have been at fault – your employer, a contractor, an occupier, a driver. WorkSafe puts it directly: a serious injury certificate alone is not enough.

TAC claims run on a parallel structure under the Transport Accident Act. An impairment determination of 30% or more means the TAC grants a serious injury certificate automatically; below 30%, you must apply for one. The TAC’s narrative wording differs subtly from the workers’ compensation wording – “serious long-term impairment” rather than “permanent serious impairment” – which is one of several reasons the two schemes should never be treated as interchangeable.

What damages cover

Two heads of loss:

  • Pain and suffering – the non-economic consequences. The injury, the surgery, the things you cannot do any more, the life you had planned.
  • Pecuniary loss – economic loss. Past and future lost earnings, lost superannuation, lost earning capacity.

Under the narrative test, a claim for economic loss carries an additional hurdle: a permanent loss of earning capacity of 40% or more.

Thresholds and caps (2026/27)

These are thresholds, not deductibles – if an assessment of a head of loss does not exceed the threshold, nothing is awarded for it.

Head of damage

WorkCover (2026/27)

TAC (2026/27)

Threshold – pain and suffering

$77,130

$70,130 (single published threshold)

Maximum – pain and suffering

$783,000

$701,620

Threshold – pecuniary loss

$79,890

see above

Maximum – pecuniary loss

$1,798,500

$1,578,760

Older claims under the Accident Compensation Act 1985 carry a different set of figures again, which is why the date of your injury matters so much.

How the two interact

This is where people get into trouble, and where early advice earns its keep.

  • You cannot run both at once. An impairment benefit claim cannot be processed while a serious injury application or common law claim is active. A claim lodged in those circumstances is treated as defective and returned.
  • An impairment claim is not compulsory – but if you make one, it must be finalised first. Before moving to common law, you must tell the agent that you accept the impairment assessment and entitlement.
  • Common law has a waiting period of its own. An application generally cannot be made until at least 18 months after the event that caused the injury, with an exception for workers who are terminally ill.
  • The impairment payment is not simply additional. In the workers’ compensation scheme, pain and suffering damages are reduced by a lump sum impairment benefit already paid. In TAC claims, the impairment lump sum is a refundable benefit, usually offset against a damages assessment.

That last point is the one most often misunderstood. “Two lump sums” does not mean two full payments stacked on top of each other. It means two pathways, with a reconciliation between them.

Which one applies to you?

A rough guide – and only a guide, because the facts drive everything:

  • Permanent injury, nobody clearly at fault: the impairment benefit is likely your pathway.
  • Permanent injury, with an unsafe system of work, a defective machine, a negligent driver or an occupier who ignored a known hazard: both pathways are potentially open, and the order you run them in matters.
  • Psychological injury: the impairment route is hard (30% WPI), but the narrative test for serious injury refers to permanent severe mental or behavioural disturbance, so common law may remain open where the impairment benefit is not.
  • Injury that has not yet stabilised: too early for either. Focus on treatment, and on protecting the claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

You can potentially access both pathways, but not simultaneously, and the impairment payment is accounted for against pain and suffering damages. The practical question is sequencing, which is why advice before lodging matters.

No. Accepting it does not extinguish a common law claim. It does have to be finalised first, and you will need to confirm to the agent that you accept the assessment before moving on.

Because the scheme uses a different assessment guide for psychiatric impairment and sets the entry point at 30% rather than 10%. It is a policy setting, not a reflection of how serious psychological injury is – and it is why many people with significant psychological injuries look to the serious injury pathway instead.

Yes. Victorian compensation figures are indexed, with TAC benefits and WorkCover statutory maximums adjusted on 1 July each year. The figures in this article are 2026/27 amounts.

Expect it to be measured in months rather than weeks at each stage. WorkSafe or the self-insurer has 120 days to respond to a serious injury application; if the application is accepted, the parties attend a conference and exchange statutory offers before proceedings can be issued.

The date of injury determines which rules and which figures apply, and limitation periods apply to both pathways. Older claims are not automatically out – but they are time-sensitive, and worth checking now rather than later.

The bottom line

Two lump sums, one claim – but not two bites of the same cherry, and not in any order you choose. The impairment benefit is the no-fault measure of permanent damage. Common law damages are the fault-based measure of what the injury has cost you. Which one is worth pursuing, and when, depends on your impairment level, the evidence of negligence, the date of your injury, and how the two will be reconciled at the end.

Find out which pathway is yours

PRD Compensation has acted for injured Victorians for more than 25 years, with offices from Dandenong and Broadmeadows to Sunshine, Collingwood, Docklands and Mildura. We will tell you honestly which lump sum is realistically available to you, in what order, and what it is likely to be worth.

Book a free, no-obligation consultation. No win, no fee.

This article is general information about Victorian law and is current as at the date of publication. It is not legal advice and does not take your circumstances into account. Compensation figures are indexed annually – check WorkSafe Victoria or the TAC for current amounts.

Key sources

PRD Compensation law logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.